Sadly there was a bad accident with an Indian Air Force Dhruv in the state of Uttar Pradesh last Friday, and we recorded that in our Safety data section here.
The “black box” – Flight Data Recorder (FDR) and Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) – are now being analysed in an attempt to find out what happened and learn from its findings. However, the FDR and CVR are being worked on by manufacturer HAL (according to this news report) and not by an independent investigation organisation just as it would be for civil accidents in most countries – the AAIB in the UK, NTSB in US, BEA in France, and so on.
We’re not saying that HAL won’t do a good job, but how credible is an investigation by an interested party? The potential exists to hide some evidence or findings. And that translates into a less-than-believable report, even if it genuinely is 100% complete. A manufacturer should be interested in the outcome of an investigation, of course, because they need to understand what part of their R&D process was below par, and how best to correct it. Nevertheless, they should also actively strive for an independent report.
The other aspect is that this is a military accident. In many countries military accidents are investigated by the military themselves. How does the legal fraternity view this? Is this independent? Interestingly, the investigation of the fatal US Air Force HH-60G Pave Hawk in the UK in January 2014 has already been released – perhaps the lack of other organisations ensured the swift conclusion and report? The UK AAIB typically takes two years to release a report on a fatal accident, by comparison
Either way, it sounds like the investigation process needs some refining.
Jeremy Parkin – HeliHub.com
- Apollo Air Services to operate first AW109 Trekker in UK
- Bermuda Aircraft Registry Hits Historic Milestone
- Air Methods opens Mercy Air 66 base at Barstow
- Heli-One wins German AS332L1 and EC215 upgrade contract
- Volocopter and Amazon join UK CAA Innovation Sandbox project
- Lilium Reveals New Air Taxi Celebrates Maiden Flight
- CareFlite celebrates 40 Year Anniversary
- Vertical Flight Society Recognizes Sikorsky For Technological Innovations
- Nepalese operators facing pilot shortage
- Sierra Nevada Awarded $75M Contract for HH-60G DVES Installations
- Sloane extend Leonardo distributorship and sign for two more AW109s
- FlightSafety announces new President & CEO
- TracPlus and IQonboard collaborate
- Northern Escape Heli Skiing Announces investment
- MALS-39 Marine recognized for contributions to maintenance readiness
- 22 countries sign new European Defence Agency cross-border agreement
- STARS announces first all-female lineup for 2019 Rescue in the Rockies
- FAA Announces Safety Rating for Costa Rica
- Speedwings expands helicopter ops with BHS and DC Aviation
- Latest ACH160 order underlines market confidence in new model